Ok, mais après tout même ajd il n'ont pas reçu leur nationalité....
Back to English:
1. 5 riders of Chatel (here Futur) lose their nationality, 4 Mexicains where he says he googled for names, 1 french he bought from the market has no name too.
2. He asks why, in the french part, explaining the googling and the problem.
3. Petit Singe tells him that it's in the wrong place. Forget the french clone. The 4 Mex, post them here, posts links for the googled names, since the committee has enough to do.
4. He comes here. Posts a link, IMO not a perfect one, but he tries. Despite the language problem, he speaks only french. So while the link is not perfect, just a site with names, not a direct link, he does something
5. He gets no answer. See my first post here. If the link is not enough, tell him that, etc.
6. He asks again.
7. Ahab answers. Says 2 ok, 2 not. It can be expected that he gave those 2 their nationality back. That's on the 29th
8. Ahab retires
9. 31st Futur seems to lose patience and asks if he gets no answer (probably meaning why still no nationality)
10. 1st of february, those 2 guys still don't have a nationality.
So? Looks to me like
a) Ahab forgot to give them their nationality back
b) after Ahab gave the nationality back somebody didn't agree and blocked the issue of the passport.
I tend to think it was b), but might be wrong.
So, if it was b), why isn't this Knöpfer not at least explaining WHY he blocked. From futurs point of view he did everything right. The ape told him to come here and post a link, he did, finally somebody answered and agreed that 2 of his 4 guys indeed deserved a nationality. But then for unknown reasons, he still doesn't get his flags back. What exactly do you expect him to do? He did what has been the rule here for ages, he still doesn't even get an explanation.
What's the problem? The links not good enough? Then TELL HIM! That now would be stepp 11. We skip that, we go to
12 Faster if I give you the links
-Gabrile Garcia. Garcia hopefully no problem, Gabrile, a clone or spelling mistake of Gabriel? Looks like it, is what I would have thought and would have taken his nationality in the first round as well. But then complaints:
http://www.babycenter.com/baby-names-gabrile-612315.htm Here it is given as a name. Probably in the site futur linked too as well. Now I don't trust those sites that much either, but at least in this one, Gabrile exists. And probably òn Futurs site, still blocked here, as well. I actually still think it's a spelling mistake... but it's in stupid lists, so a case that can go both ways. Give it to him but tell him to pay attention to spelling mistakes in stupid babynamesites, or say that unless he produces a real person named Gabrile (maybe exists after all) he can't use the name.
But you have to tell him That
IS your job. It's not your job to google all the names, but it is your job to answer to inquiries. Again, for Futur the last he heard was, Gabrile Garcia is ok, he can be Mexican. Now it seems he can't. He needs to know why. How can you expect people to know what is ok if you don't tell them?
-Gabiel Abriaz. Abriaz the problem? Won't google for that, but too me it sounds spanish. I guess it's Gabiel. Another spelling problem of Gabriel. Link:
http://www.babynamespedia.com/meaning/Gabiel
Still only a babyname site, but with the explanation, related names, meaning, etc. it looks trustworthy enough. To me. This one I would allow myself. But the main problem in the end is the same. If you don't, post the reasons, again, from Futurs point of view he did everything he had to do. If his link wasn't enough, you have to tell him that.
13. POST WHY THOSE 2 GUYS DON'T HAVE A NATIONALITY YET. After it was said by a then member of the committee that they would get one. Now something changed? WHAT? FUTUR HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW, HE NEEDS TO KNOW. You want to frustrate people? They have to guess
Exactly the same problem with Mangahn (Harry Potter). You all know what I think of him, still, even HE deserves an answer with explanation. NO, because xxx. If somebody complains, and the answer is NO, that is needed. Always. If then the discussion goes overboard, endless arguments, of course nobody can force you to stay in, you say what your opinion is, what you need for the name to pass. Then you have done your job, unless something new comes up, no need to answer. Of course in cases like Draco Malfoy would be nice to know if there is a rule.. .for characters of novels/movies etc.
The same with Steinz too. There was a discussion, but without you guys. IT'S YOU THAT need to tell Steinz why he can't have swedish Dotters. (He's Austrian, his wife toom, they live in Austria, so his daughters have to be Austrian) You think somebody else explained it. Ok, then just say: I agree with xyz assessment, not possible like that. But you need to say something.
14: COMMUNICATION.
Rhetorische Frage.
