Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Discussion about fairness-stuff. Advices of breach of rules and so on.

Moderators: systemmods, fairplaymods

Post Reply
schappy
Posts: 419
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 11:10 pm
Contact:

Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by schappy » Thu Jan 16, 2025 4:25 pm

Km: 147, Steigung: -7

Charles Coco (essor team) attackiert

Gerard Naho (essor team) attackiert

Bernard Baba (essor team) attackiert
Out of the same group, more then 10 km to the finish line


edited by flockmastoR to add information in the title
I´ve got the magic in me

Tukhtahuaev
Posts: 349
Joined: Fri May 13, 2016 7:07 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack

Post by Tukhtahuaev » Thu Jan 16, 2025 6:00 pm

FPC is investigating the case!

NBeullens
Posts: 8
Joined: Thu Nov 07, 2024 6:35 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by NBeullens » Thu Jan 16, 2025 9:55 pm

I do want to back up Essor. it is only his 12th race and most of them are at Vietnam. He probably doesnt know or doesnt really understand the rule. So i don't think he should get a fine or even a warning. He should probably have someone explain him the rule and that's it :)

ATB - Racing
Posts: 305
Joined: Fri May 04, 2012 11:57 am
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by ATB - Racing » Thu Jan 16, 2025 10:57 pm

sounds reasonable.
doesnt that happen?

zizou
Posts: 35
Joined: Wed Sep 02, 2015 9:45 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by zizou » Fri Jan 17, 2025 12:24 am

I wouldnt have made a fairplay case. He is a rookie und the attack had no influence. Was for p20 or something like that.

Only thing is, that he showed no reaction to the chat and continued with all 3 riders. But he didnt respond to any chat the whole tour…

schappy
Posts: 419
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 11:10 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by schappy » Fri Jan 17, 2025 1:25 am

How should he learn the rules, if nobody says hm, that he do something wrong? The FPC knows all of this and of course he will not get a fine.
I´ve got the magic in me

Elaska
Posts: 677
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 10:14 am
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by Elaska » Fri Jan 17, 2025 3:42 am

NBeullens wrote:
Thu Jan 16, 2025 9:55 pm
I do want to back up Essor. it is only his 12th race and most of them are at Vietnam. He probably doesnt know or doesnt really understand the rule. So i don't think he should get a fine or even a warning. He should probably have someone explain him the rule and that's it :)
Unfortunately for some managers it's easier to open a fpc against a newcomer than to try to explain him in the race chat what he did wrong, so he can learn.
Unfortunately these remains always the same ones and the first ones to complain that newcomers aren't attracted by the game...
2024-01-30 Big Donkey Elaska 1 Good move, good reading of the race, just the sprint didn't work out. High quality racing.

schappy
Posts: 419
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 11:10 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by schappy » Fri Jan 17, 2025 7:53 am

Elaska

I Wrote him in the Chat, he doesnt react!

So stop talking bullshit about me an how i open fairplay cases!
I´ve got the magic in me

User avatar
flockmastoR
Posts: 3466
Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2010 11:42 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by flockmastoR » Fri Jan 17, 2025 9:25 am

He needs to understand, that what he did is a violation of the fairplay rules. Until now he didn't react.

A report is necessarry of course. There is absolutely no reason to blame Schappy for anything here. He was the only one in the chat pointing out the violation to Essor. Maybe it would have helped if some other managers supported the claim of Schappy in the race chat.

And this is seperated from what the actual decision will be. You can let newcomers get away with something the first time if you have the impression that they understand that a mistake has been made. But thats something to discuss for the FPC
Boaz Trakhtenbrot:
  • Winner Giro 2022
  • 10 GC wins
  • 16.609 Eternal Points
__________________
Schrödinger's Dogs: Alive & Dead

Elaska
Posts: 677
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2010 10:14 am
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by Elaska » Fri Jan 17, 2025 1:53 pm

schappy wrote:
Fri Jan 17, 2025 7:53 am
Elaska

I Wrote him in the Chat, he doesnt react!

So stop talking bullshit about me an how i open fairplay cases!
Open a fpc for that too.

He said 'bonjour' the first day so I guess he must be French. The next days the chat was full in German. Not sure he was still reading it.
2024-01-30 Big Donkey Elaska 1 Good move, good reading of the race, just the sprint didn't work out. High quality racing.

schappy
Posts: 419
Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 11:10 pm
Contact:

Re: Essor team Team attack - St 10 Tour of Vietnam 14h

Post by schappy » Fri Jan 17, 2025 2:28 pm

Elaska wrote:
Fri Jan 17, 2025 1:53 pm
schappy wrote:
Fri Jan 17, 2025 7:53 am
Elaska

I Wrote him in the Chat, he doesnt react!

So stop talking bullshit about me an how i open fairplay cases!
Open a fpc for that too.

He said 'bonjour' the first day so I guess he must be French. The next days the chat was full in German. Not sure he was still reading it.
------------- 2025-01-09 -------------
Kreatief(15:58): i take it
Tukhtahuaev(15:57): Most likely
Kreatief(15:56): easy catch if Schappy dont attack
Tukhtahuaev(15:53): I have to say that I am very annoyed by now
Lotto-Soudal(15:52): Gw
Schappy(15:51): gw Kreatief
Schappy(15:42): Sunwebde let the favo work
Kreatief(15:41): he is the favo
Kreatief(15:41): let me fight against Schappy
Kreatief(15:41): common sun
Sunwebde(15:18): Kreatif can you do the flat and i will do the Mountain?
Tukhtahuaev(15:14): I would prefer to wait for group 4
Sunwebde(15:14): Help in Group 3?
T-Mobile-A(15:03): and Verbnjak is tired after two attacks and two sprints
T-Mobile-A(15:03): have to leave for some minutes later as well
T-Mobile-A(14:58): had to do something
T-Mobile-A(14:58): Forgot Rantala in pace, sorry
Kreatief(14:58): T-Mob better ride in front with me
T-Mobile-A(14:56): after two attacks there is no helper saving advantage :D
T-Mobile-A(14:55): no helper saving, sry
T-Mobile-A(14:53): Einkemmer was on loose
Tukhtahuaev(14:49): Even -12 barely a sieb
zizou(14:48): oh come on
T-Mobile-A(14:44): ok
Sunwebde(14:43): For me we can stop in Front, Mountain points are not worth it
T-Mobile-A(14:42): sunweb???
Schappy(14:40): she can not win, when the attack button is in use
T-Mobile-A(14:40): bäh, both offline
T-Mobile-A(14:39): Natalijo not
Schappy(14:39): they all have enough dh
T-Mobile-A(14:39): sunwebde and zizou...we are back in pace in front
T-Mobile-A(14:38): with heavy rain you could even sieb the favo maybe
T-Mobile-A(14:38): true
Tukhtahuaev(14:37): You have to hope for km98
T-Mobile-A(14:37): bäh! no sieb
T-Mobile-A(14:36): but I like the riders name
T-Mobile-A(14:36): tricky Kreatief
zizou(14:28): Ok
Sunwebde(14:27): Im into the Deal if we can agree
T-Mobile-A(14:27): so everybody out of pace? @zizou @sunwebde?
Sunwebde(14:26): Im back
Tukhtahuaev(14:26): If I could decide I would also onlyallow male names. Or alternatively only female names
T-Mobile-A(14:25): sounds good. hope sunwebde is back soon
Tukhtahuaev(14:25): I would like a bit of rolling
T-Mobile-A(14:24): but everybody can do it like he want
T-Mobile-A(14:24): no. one is your thinking, the other is when I have a look at the names the thinking of the mass
T-Mobile-A(14:24): tough conditions. is the peloton interested in a deal with no pace?
Schappy(14:23): its only your thinking and my thinking
T-Mobile-A(14:22): so...what's your point?
T-Mobile-A(14:22): because men cycling is much more popular and 97 % teams have mens riders
Schappy(14:22): why you think, its men cycling here?
T-Mobile-A(14:21): it's no mixed cycling usually
T-Mobile-A(14:21): you have only mens with womens name, crazy
Schappy(14:20): dont know why your ladies have men names
Schappy(14:19): no a woman rider
T-Mobile-A(14:19): a mens rider with womens name
Schappy(14:18): now i found her
Schappy(14:17): searching a few minutes to see a Natalija
T-Mobile-A(14:12): Natalija looks decent, that's a fact
Tukhtahuaev(14:11): Your advantage is that you have a lot of options
T-Mobile-A(14:11): hmmm...difficult. his best helper is having fun in front
Kreatief(14:11): nahh common i need a lot of luck and i got a lack of sprint
T-Mobile-A(14:11): so no Hajek solo win? :D
Kreatief(14:10): some classics and some classics with sprint
Tukhtahuaev(14:10): In my opinion biggest chances today for Schappy, Kreatief and me
T-Mobile-A(14:10): who is stage favo btw.? :D
T-Mobile-A(14:10): if sunweb joins, we can continue. otherwise I stop after km 30
zizou(14:09): If sunweb joins again
Kreatief(14:09): will stop, isnt my stage
T-Mobile-A(14:08): we wanna go on or stop? on the one hand it would be better for me, if everybody is catched. but we can go on aswell. no further attacks planned
zizou(14:08): Sunwebde?
T-Mobile-A(14:05): thx tukh
T-Mobile-A(14:04): aaaah ok
Tukhtahuaev(14:04): Auto resfresh is active
T-Mobile-A(14:04): what does the star mean next to the teamname?
Tukhtahuaev(14:01): Hello
Lotto-Soudal(13:57): Hello
Schappy(13:53): okay, so it isnt my mistake
T-Mobile-A(13:53): its upside down
Schappy(13:51): Points jersey tab is not correct, or is it only at my team?
T-Mobile-A(13:42): hi
Schappy(13:21): hello
------------- 2025-01-08 -------------
Narrenparty(16:12): klar
T-Mobile-A(16:09): ajo. aber du verstehst meinen frust wohl auch denk ich
Narrenparty(16:07): ich kann bei 200 aber auch nicht warten, wenn hinter mir einer los sprintet
Narrenparty(16:06): nächstes mal hänge ich nicht an dir Tmobile
T-Mobile-A(16:05): yeah doppelsieg
Narrenparty(16:04): oh doch nicht, sorry
Narrenparty(16:03): reicht doch für p2
Tukhtahuaev(16:02): Barth darf nächstes Mal wenigstens von 100m gehen
Narrenparty(16:02): was hätte ich anders machen sollen aus dieser situation ?
T-Mobile-A(16:01): bin ja selber schuld. viele hätten einen tricksprint gemacht und Amundsen abgehängt von Rantala
T-Mobile-A(16:01): jetzt bin ich halt komplett antisprint, so isses sinnlos
Narrenparty(16:01): was hätte ich tun sollen?
Narrenparty(16:00): sorry, ich habe keine andere möglichkeit
T-Mobile-A(16:00): oh from 200, thank you buddy! how nice!
T-Mobile-A(16:00): yeah
T-Mobile-A(16:00): ok, 6th place is free
T-Mobile-A(15:58): you bring everybody in front of me at the end
T-Mobile-A(15:58): usually I have to consider
T-Mobile-A(15:58): and I'm not the guy for tricksprints
T-Mobile-A(15:58): and now I'm fucked^1000
Narrenparty(15:57): i did my own train, but yours was stronger
T-Mobile-A(15:56): for the future
T-Mobile-A(15:56): will keep that in my mind
T-Mobile-A(15:56): not really fair to hang like this
Kreatief(15:44): thank you
Sunwebde(15:44): Yeah it could habe worked without a Quick reaction
Tukhtahuaev(15:43): Was a nice try though
Narrenparty(15:38): yes, go a lot of work shortly
Tukhtahuaev(15:36): And Narren should wake up
Tukhtahuaev(15:35): Disrupts the harmony here
T-Mobile-A(15:34): great attack from Kreatief tbh
Kreatief(15:33): why?
Tukhtahuaev(15:32): I'm not the biggest fan
Sunwebde(15:31): Quite a nice attack
Tukhtahuaev(15:25): If you have any questions just ask
Tukhtahuaev(15:24): Your strategy doesn't seem to make a lot of sense here, essor team
T-Mobile-A(15:24): if you need any help, just ask @essor team
Sunwebde(15:11): Yeah:)
Schappy(15:10): now you know
Sunwebde(15:09): Ah oke didn't now that
Tukhtahuaev(15:08): In tours you don't go out of tempo after 15km
Sunwebde(15:07): How can He still be in Tempo of hes offline?
T-Mobile-A(15:06): duuurch
T-Mobile-A(14:38): but no...there is no sprinter
T-Mobile-A(14:38): maybe he wants to collect money but want a sprint
Tukhtahuaev(14:36): That's definitely a good way to waste energy
zizou(14:36): Genau.
Schappy(14:32): one star should be auto refresh
Schappy(14:31): essor Team, why you chasing your own guy?
Kreatief(14:31): warum ist bei sunwebde ein Stern?
zizou(14:08): Sprint klingt gut
T-Mobile-A(14:03): I won't be here every race I fear
Tukhtahuaev(14:03): Why no Krieger, TMA?
Sunwebde(14:02): Hi
Tukhtahuaev(13:56): Bin bei nem Sprint dabei
T-Mobile-A(13:56): hi
Narrenparty(13:55): Jemand interesse an einem Sprint heute?
Tukhtahuaev(13:51): Hello
Narrenparty(13:48): hi
Kreatief(13:48): hi
essor team(13:39): bonjour
Schappy(13:34): hello

Chat from the first two days, german was not very much to see (and only much after the race) and he was two times directly ask something. No Rection, the other not german guy doenst talk more then "hello" so we began talking more german. But i dont know, why this is now something for the Team-Attack? or only to annoy me?
I´ve got the magic in me

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests